i cant believe this isnt further up the list of hotels, there are so many hotels in key west and this one looked much better than the rest of them. the room is gorgeous, with a big 4 poster and comfy bed, there was a living room area and a balcony that looked over the pool and the kitchen area... more

First time to the keys.......where to stay? So, this resort is really easy to find provided you go NORTH on roosevelt road when you leave U.S 1. Banana bay is set in quite spacious grounds with palms and banana plants everywhere. Reception was very helpful on check in and every time we needed help to get a cab they were... more

My husband and I were spending 2 weeks in the Key. We came across this hotel by accident. During the search of past reviews we found many that indicated the pool was clothing optional. So when I called, the staff said this was an adult resort and the pool was clothing optional. We were staying at the Crown Plaza the... more

The accomidations were nice and the hotel staff was very accomidating during our stay. The dolphin and snorkling trip that the hotel works with was great. That is the upside. The downside was that when we first booked the hotel, we were under the impression that it was a clothing optional / adults only location. We found that that had... more

My husband and I stayed at Banana Bay for 4 nights. We had a nightmarish trip down (we were supposed to get into Miami at 2:30 p.m. and drive down to Key West but ended up not getting to Key West until almost 2 a.m. due to various airplane issues and delays). I called to let them know that we... more

The staff was very nice, the room was quite good (althought the cofee maker was missing some parts and did not work) with cool balcony. First place in the US I have seen who were so polite to smokers they put an ashtray on the table. The pool is o.k., jacuzzi is o.k., the beach - let me tell you... more

Did alot of research for a very special trip with my 25 year old daughter. She flew in from Cincinnati (I live in Fort Myers, FL) and we drove down (5 hours on a good day)and arrived at the Banana Bay Motel at approx. 3:30 p.m. When we first pulled in to the parking lot, my heart sank to the... more

I stayed at the Banana Bay Resort in Key West in April for my honeymoon. The resort and the staff’s service exceeded my expectations. Dana there helped me to make prior arrangements in decorating the room with flowers/rose petals and chocolate covered strawberries as a surprise for my wife upon check-in. They also provided me the room with the best... more

Stayed at the hotel May 08 - rooms are beautiful (ask for 2nd floor for best views), everything was very clean and staff friendly. It is located on the main road but you woudnt know it because the rooms are secluded. It is nowhere near Duval street and doesnt have the "old key west" feel, so you cannot walk anywhere... more